Delivery, Rules and Ordering

Menthol Cigarettes in Canada: What the Ban Actually Covers

What the menthol cigarettes Canada ban covers: sold here, made for export, pouches and possession

Menthol cigarettes have been off the legal Canadian market since 2 October 2017, when the federal menthol order took effect.3 The rule is an additive prohibition, and it is narrower and stranger than the word ban suggests.

Search for menthol cigarettes canada and you will get shops selling them on one half of the page and a Government of Canada notice banning them on the other. Both are accurate. Here’s the part that reconciles them, taken straight from the statute rather than from anyone’s summary of it.

Are menthol cigarettes banned in Canada?

Yes. Menthol is a prohibited additive, and has been since 2 October 2017.

The mechanism matters more than the headline. The Tobacco and Vaping Products Act doesn’t ban a product called a menthol cigarette. It bans an ingredient, then lists which products the ban applies to. Schedule 1 item 1.2 names “Menthol, including l-menthol, and menthone, including l-menthone” in column 1, and in column 2 it gives the products caught: “Tobacco products, except those that are manufactured or sold for export”.1

So menthol cigarettes are illegal to make and to sell in Canada in the sense that the additive cannot lawfully be put in them. That’s a real prohibition with real force. It just isn’t the blanket ban most pages describe, and the next two sections are why.

What the menthol cigarettes Canada ban covers: sold here, made for export, pouches and possession
The ban reaches the additive, not the smoker.

Who the menthol ban actually binds

Manufacturers. Not shops, and not you.

The two operative sections are short enough to read in full. Section 5.1(1): “No manufacturer shall use an additive set out in column 1 of Schedule 1 in the manufacture of a tobacco product set out in column 2.” Section 5.2: “No manufacturer shall sell a tobacco product set out in column 2 of Schedule 1 that contains an additive set out in column 1.”1

Both say no manufacturer. That’s the whole point. Elsewhere in the same Act, Parliament wrote “No person shall sell a tobacco product that is packaged in a manner that is contrary to the provisions of this Act”, and “No person, unless exempted by the regulations, shall sell a tobacco product by means of a display that permits a person to handle the tobacco product before paying for it”.1 When the drafters meant everyone, they said person. In the additive sections they said manufacturer.

That’s why nothing in these rules makes it an offence to possess or smoke a menthol cigarette. The prohibition operates upstream, at the factory and at the manufacturer’s point of sale, which is the standard way Canada regulates what goes into a product.

Menthol cigarettes Canada ban dates: in force 2 October 2017, 180 days after publication
Registered March 2017, in force that October.

The export exemption written into the law

Read column 2 of item 1.2 again: tobacco products, except those that are manufactured or sold for export.1

Menthol tobacco can still be made in Canada perfectly lawfully, as long as it’s going somewhere else. The ban is about what Canadians can be sold, not about menthol itself being treated as too dangerous to produce. That exemption isn’t hidden in a regulation somewhere; it’s in the same line of the same schedule as the prohibition.

It’s a useful corrective if you’ve read that Canada decided menthol was uniquely harmful. The policy goal was the domestic market and, in the government’s own framing, youth appeal. Health Canada said the amendment would “expand flavour restrictions to 95% of the entire tobacco market in Canada”.2 Ninety-five, not a hundred, and the government chose that number deliberately.

When Canada banned menthol, and what came before it

The menthol order was registered on 24 March 2017 and published in the Canada Gazette on 5 April 2017. Its coming-into-force clause reads: “This Order comes into force on the 180th day after the day on which it is published in the Canada Gazette, Part II.”3 The 180th day after 5 April 2017 is 2 October 2017, and that’s the date menthol left the legal Canadian market.

It didn’t arrive out of nowhere. Health Canada described it as building on restrictions that came into force in 2009 and 2015, which had already banned additives like chocolate and bubble gum flavours in cigarettes, blunt wraps and most cigars.2 Menthol was carved out of those earlier rounds. The 2017 order is what removed the carve-out.

The order as made covered “cigarettes, blunt wraps and most cigars sold on the Canadian market”.2 The consolidated schedule today is broader still, reaching tobacco products generally.1 If you’re wondering why older articles and newer ones describe different scopes, that’s the reason, and both were right when written.

Why shops still list menthol cigarettes

Because the legal prohibition and the actual market are two different questions, and this is the part the ranking pages leave out.

The brands still sold as menthol in Canada are native brands, manufactured on reserve. Look at who ranks for menthol cigarettes canada and it’s plain enough: retailers tied to Six Nations and Mohawk communities, alongside general native tobacco shops. Federal additive rules bind manufacturers, and they have not been enforced against on-reserve manufacturing the way they have against the national tobacco companies.

Shortened to cig, the questions people ask here are the same ones. Searches for menthol cig brands, or for cig online, land on shops selling native product for exactly the reason above: those are the brands still carrying menthol, and the federal additive rule is what removed everyone else from that shelf. Our comparison of native and regular cigarettes goes through what does and does not differ between them.

We’re not going to dress that up as an exemption, because the statute doesn’t contain one. There’s no line in Schedule 1 that carves out on-reserve production the way there’s a line carving out export.1 What there is, is a gap between a rule and its enforcement, and that gap is the entire reason this search result looks the way it does.

That’s the honest answer to can you still buy menthol cigarettes in canada. The product is findable. The additive rule that makes it non-compliant hasn’t gone anywhere, and no shop, ours included, can change that by writing something different on a page.

Menthol pouches and vapes are a different category

Here’s where the law genuinely does treat menthol differently, and it’s the most useful distinction on this page.

Item 1.2 applies to tobacco products.1 A nicotine pouch isn’t one. It contains nicotine but no tobacco leaf, which puts it outside Schedule 1 entirely and under a separate regime. That’s why menthol and mint pouches are the flavours you’ll still see, and our guide to pouch rules in Canada covers what does govern them, which is authorisation rather than additives.

So menthol as a flavour isn’t outlawed in Canada across the board. It’s prohibited as an additive in tobacco products. Move to a product that isn’t tobacco and the rule doesn’t follow. Our nicotine pouches and ZYN pages list what we carry in that category, and the ZYN in Canada guide explains where that brand stands.

Can you bring menthol cigarettes into Canada?

The additive sections don’t speak to it. As set out above, sections 5.1 and 5.2 bind manufacturers, so a traveller carrying cigarettes for personal use isn’t who those provisions are addressed to.1

That isn’t the same as saying anything goes at the border. Personal importation of tobacco runs into customs allowances, duty and provincial rules, none of which live in the Tobacco and Vaping Products Act, and none of which this page can answer for your particular trip. What we can tell you is that the menthol prohibition itself is not a possession offence, because it was never written as one.

Border and duty questions are worth checking directly with the Canada Border Services Agency rather than taking any retailer’s word for it, ours included.

What this means if you are looking for menthol

Four things worth holding onto, and none of them need you to trust a shop page.

  • The ban is real and dated. 2 October 2017, by order SOR/2017-45.3
  • It targets an additive, not a habit. The sections bind manufacturers, which is why possession was never the issue.1
  • It carves out export. Menthol tobacco made in Canada for other markets is lawful, and that’s in the schedule itself.1
  • Pouches are outside it. Not tobacco products, so not caught by item 1.2.1

For the rest of what we stock, the flavoured range and discount lines are the pages to compare, and the full brand list shows who makes what. If you got here from a Marlboro search, the Marlboro in Canada guide covers that brand’s Canadian position, and the warning label rules explain the other half of what’s printed on a legal Canadian pack. Delivery terms are on the shipping policy and every order passes age verification first. For flavoured little cigars, our cigarillos in Canada guide covers the rules.

Common questions

Are menthol cigarettes banned in Canada?

Yes. Menthol and menthone are prohibited additives under Schedule 1 of the Tobacco and Vaping Products Act, and the prohibition took effect on 2 October 2017. The rule bans the additive in tobacco products rather than banning possession.

When did Canada ban menthol cigarettes?

The Order Amending the Schedule to the Tobacco Act (Menthol) was registered on 24 March 2017 and published on 5 April 2017. It came into force on the 180th day after publication, which is 2 October 2017.

Why are menthol cigarettes banned in Canada?

Health Canada framed it as extending existing flavour restrictions, which had already removed additives such as chocolate and bubble gum in 2009 and 2015. The department said the menthol amendment would expand flavour restrictions to 95 percent of the entire Canadian tobacco market.

Are menthol cigarettes illegal to smoke in Canada?

No. Sections 5.1 and 5.2 of the Act are addressed to manufacturers, not to individuals. Other parts of the same Act say no person shall, so the narrower wording in the additive sections is deliberate. Possession and use are not what these provisions regulate.

Can you still buy menthol cigarettes in Canada?

They are still sold, by native retailers and manufacturers on reserve. The federal additive prohibition has not been enforced against on-reserve manufacturing the way it has against national tobacco companies. There is no exemption in the statute for it.

Does the menthol ban apply to nicotine pouches?

No. Schedule 1 item 1.2 applies to tobacco products, and a nicotine pouch contains no tobacco. Menthol and mint pouches fall under a separate authorisation regime instead of the additive rules.

Can menthol cigarettes still be made in Canada?

Yes, for export. Column 2 of item 1.2 exempts tobacco products that are manufactured or sold for export, so menthol tobacco produced in Canada for other markets is outside the prohibition.

Where to go from here

The short version: menthol cigarettes left the legal Canadian market on 2 October 2017 under an additive prohibition that binds manufacturers, exempts anything made for export, and doesn’t reach nicotine pouches at all. The shops you can still find selling them are native brands made on reserve, and that’s an enforcement gap rather than an exemption.

If you’re comparing what we actually carry, start with the flavoured cigarettes listing, the native cigarettes range and the current specials.

Sources

  1. Tobacco and Vaping Products Act, S.C. 1997, c. 13, sections 5.1 and 5.2 and Schedule 1, consolidated text, Justice Laws Website
  2. Health Canada, Government of Canada finalizes ban on menthol in most tobacco products, 5 April 2017
  3. Order Amending the Schedule to the Tobacco Act (Menthol), SOR/2017-45, Canada Gazette Part II, 5 April 2017
Cheap Online Smokes Team

About Cheap Online Smokes Team

The team behind Cheap Online Smokes, a Canadian online tobacco retailer shipping nationwide.